The past four days have seen tragic climbing accidents on Oregon's Mount
Hood
and Washington's Mount Rainier, two of the most popular of the Cascade
volcanoes. The Hood accident was followed by the incident rescuers fear
most: the crash of a rescue helicopter.
The incidents hit especially close to home for me, and not just because I'm
a mountaineering journalist: the accidents occurred on routes that are
included in
the guidebook to the range, Selected Climbs in the Cascades, that I wrote
with Jim Nelson.
And the helicopter incident is eerily familiar to one I experienced myself
in 1988. After a bone-crushing leader fall deep in the wilderness Cascades,
I was plucked from a mountain side by a courageous army helicopter pilot who
made multiple attempts to retrieve me, and had to contend with the same
problems that plagued the rescuers on Mount Hood: downdrafts and holding a
hover at high altitude.
According to chief climbing ranger at Mount Rainier National Park, Mike
Gauthier, the facts of the Liberty Ridge accident are these: last weekend,
a party of four
climbers, including 21-year-old Keeta Owens and Corneilius Beilharz, 26,
both students from Oregon
State University, and two friends from Germany, Grit Kleinshchmidt, 26,
and Andreas Kurth, 29, set out to climb Liberty Ridge on
14,410-foot Mount Rainier. The route is usually done in three to five days:
two days to high camp at Thumb Rock (10,500 feet on Liberty Ridge), a day on
the upper ridge, then down, usually by the Emmons Glacier route, as Liberty
Ridge is too technical to descend safely. Many parties camp on or near the
summit, others climb the upper ridge and descend the same day. The route is
more technical than most glacier routes on the mountain, but it's chief
characteristic is that it is committing: descent down the ridge is
difficult.
The climbers were on schedule, camping Sunday night at Thumb Rock, Gauthier
said. Climbers who had seen them report that they were moving well. But the
party
made slow progress Monday and only just reached the top of the ridge,
according to Gauthier. The climbers
decided to bivouac near Liberty Cap when their GPS equipment became
inoperable in the freezing rain, making route-finding for the descent
impossible in the bad conditions. Tuesday the weather worsened yet, and
the party was forced to make yet another bivouac in shallow snow caves. One
member of the party, Beilharz, apparently fell to his death during the
night; another, Kurth,
fell but survived, and the next day managed to descend (climbing despite the
fact one of his plastic climbing boot had been lost in the fall) the
Winthrop Glacier solo. Rangers state he was lucky not to have fallen in a
crevasse while climbing alone and unroped. When the climber encountered
another party near St. Elmo Pass, he borrowed a cell phone to alert rangers
to the accident. The response was quick, but both women were dead when
rangers reached the scene of the bivouac; their bodies were found
approximately 350 feet below the bivouac site.
"This was especially tough," said Gauthier. "I've been on a lot of
recoveries, but never for female climbers before. And these people were
mostly very young. It's never easy, but this one has hit us especially
hard."
On Mount Hood, the usual crowds were ascending the popular South Side route
on the 11,237-foot mountain, sometimes called the Hogsback or Palmer
Snowfield route. It's one of the most popular moderate routes on any volcano
in the range.
I climbed it first in 1980, leaving at sunset so my partners and I could
climb under a full moon and have the route to ourselves. An ascent normally
is done in a day, with no camp, as the ski area on the south side of Hood
makes for excellent access to this route.
The South Side route is not technically demanding in most conditions, but on
Thursday the route was particularly icy near the top, where the route
narrows before entering the so-called "chute," a steep gully that leads to
the summit. Rangers reported that one party of two climbers, roped together,
lost footing and fell. As those climbers tumbled down the mountain, out of
control, they became entangled with another party of three climbers just
below them. The second party was dragged down the mountain as well.
All of the climbers were now falling, and yet a third party of
climbers were caught up in the fall. All the falling climbers ended up in a
crevasse at approximately 10,500 feet. Three climbers were killed: John
Biggs, 62, of Windsor, California, and William Ward, 49, and Richard Read,
48, of Forest Grove, Oregon.
Thursday afternoon, a U.S. Air Force Pave Hawk helicopter attempted to
rescue the surviving climbers from the area of the crevasse. But the
dramatic footage shown worldwide on television clearly revealed that the
machine lost lift, wobbled, and crashed into the slope. It then tumbled for
several hundred feet before coming to a rest. Fortunately, none of
the six man crew was killed, but several were seriously injured.
It was a bleak day for climbers in the Cascades, a great range for climbing,
but it was not the worst day. That dubious distinction goes to an incident
on Mount Rainier in June 1981, when an ice cliff avalanched,
killing 11 people. An incident on Mount Hood in 1986 also claimed 11 lives, when a group
of students and teachers were caught in bad weather and perished before
rescuers could reach them.
These incidents underscore the danger of climbing on the Cascade volcanoes.
They are some of the most appealing peaks in the lower 48, clad with
glaciers and ice that give the feel of big mountains. But conditions can
change rapidly, allowing minor incidents to escalate into major disasters.
Weather and white-out contribute to most accidents recorded
on the peaks.
I climbed in the Cascades for decades thinking I would not experience an
accident myself. That changed in 1988, when I took a 150-foot leader fall on
Chimney Rock, a 7,680-foot spire in the Alpine Lakes Wilderness of the
Cascades. With a compound fracture protruding from my body, I spent a couple
of dreadful days bleeding on a tiny ledge while my partner went for help. It
was more than 15 miles to the nearest trailhead. By dusk, at the end of the
second day, climbers had lowered me to a glacier below the rock spire.
There,
a U.S. Army helicopter pilot name Gregory Kreuger made multiple attempts to
evacuate me from the steep glacier. Lying on the slope, I was sure the pilot
was going to give up: it was windy, it was getting dark, and the pilot was
above operating
ceiling for his Huey. But pilot Greg Kreuger later told me, "We had been
told that
if we couldn't get you off the mountain, you were going to die. So we kept
trying."
Later, while researching a book about the accident (In the Zone, The
Mountaineers Books, Seattle) I asked Kreuger what is was like flying in the
thin air of the mountains, where downdrafts and random winds can send the
helicopter careening into the slope.
"When flying helicopters," Kreuger told me, " there's a transition from the
clean air of altitude to the dirty air of ground effect. That's called
effective transitional lift, the transition from flying to hovering. That's
what you must deal with when plucking someone off a mountain slope. But it's
tricky, you
don't want to go into ground effect too soon because then you're exposed to
any
sudden downdraft or windshift."
"For you, we got in close, and I was surprised to see the angle of the
glacier was much steeper than I had expected. I was just about to the point
where I'd go into ground effect mode when I suddenly lost tail rotor effect.
When that happens you lose control. At that point you don't think about the
injured guy, you think about your crew. I was able to save the situation by
going slightly nose down and just falling away down the valley."
"In your case, I decided to keep trying to get you off until the fuel
situation got
critical. But the thing about mountain flying is that winds are very
changeable. You constantly have to make decisionswhat is the best angle,
the best direction of approach? What are the winds at the surface? Can you
hold the hover?"
Kreuger eventually flew his machine close enough to the slope of the
glacier, placing one skid on the slope, that rescuers could literally toss
my broken body on board. In an hour, I
was at the best trauma center on the West Coast. Kreuger and his crew had
saved my life, and no one else was injured in the process. I was lucky.
The tragic events of the last week show that, even when there are courageous
and willing rescue personnel, the outcome is not always the desired one. The
Cascades, like all mountains, harbor lethal dangers. It's incumbent on
climbers to exercise the best judgement, and have proper skills, before
venturing into the peaks. For when climbers need help, that puts others in
harms
way. And too often, the outcome is another tragedy, as we saw this week.
Peter Potterfield, MountainZone.com staff