|
Repelling Biting Nasties
Since the first human hand-swatted in vain at swarming mosquitoes, man has been valiantly trying to repel an insect onslaught every time he heads outdoors -- for good reason. Mosquitoes, fleas, ticks and black flies all have bites which can cause painful irritations at best and debilitating or fatal diseases at worst. Besides dressing in light colored clothing that protects as much of the skin surface as possible, using a repellent can help to prevent bites. Despite fears of DEET (N,N diethyl-m-toluamide)-associated health risks (risks the DEET manufacturers vehemently deny, pointing to reams of scientific study) and the increased attention given natural alternatives, DEET-based repellents are still acknowledged as the best alternative when serious insect protection is required. Despite the manufacturer-led downplay of DEET risks, it does seem logical to assume that if DEET can peel paint, melt nylon, destroy plastic, wreck wood finishes and damage fishing line, then it must be hell on the skin -- perhaps worse. It is being theorized by a growing number in the scientific community that repeated applications of products containing low-percentage levels of DEET actually creates a greater risk for absorbing high levels of DEET into the body than one application of a 30- to 50-percent DEET product with an effectiveness of four to six hours. Also being studied is the possibility that low levels of DEET, which might not otherwise be of toxicological concern, may become hazardous if they are formulated with solvents/dilutents (considered inactive ingredients) which may enhance the absorption rate. How safe are natural alternatives? It is important to remember that essential oils, while derived from plants that grow naturally, are chemicals too. Some are potentially hazardous if ingested and most are downright painful if they find their way into the eyes or onto mucus membranes. Citronella products work for up to two hours to repel mosquitoes, flies, gnats and midges and then require reapplication (the same holds true for other natural formulations). Products using low-percentage levels of DEET also require reapplication every two hours to remain effective, increasing the potential for higher absorption rate. That said, I would suggest that if you're going outside for only a short period in an environment where insect bites are more an irritant than a hazard, you would do just as well to go natural.
Peeking at the products: Deep Woods Off! by Johnson Wax This seems to be a camp favorite, because its aerosol method of application helps it go on evenly. Still, because the percentage of DEET (28.5-percent) is somewhat higher, it's not recommended for kids (American Academy of Pediatricians recommends that children should not use insect repellents with more than a 10-percent formulation of DEET). I found it repels well for around five hours and disappears quickly into the skin, leaving only a slight tacky feeling behind.
DEET Plus by Sawyer Products Lotion application: it has a 17.5-percent mix of DEET, but because of the synergist, claims minimal DEET absorption. Applying it was easy, although it left a somewhat thin, greasy film behind. Seemed effective for around four hours. Since it has a fly repellent, it worked better against deer flies and black flies than DEET products alone.
Naturapel by Tender Pump application with a 10-percent blend of citronella. Its effectiveness lasted just under two hours and, after several applications, my skin felt a bit sticky. The citronella scent takes a little getting used to.
Ben's 100 by Tender Serious bug juice for serious conditions. One application of this 100-percent DEET product leaves the outdoors person good-to-go for up to ten hours without fear of bites. The drawbacks are it is oily, smelly and, since it is so concentrated, places the user at a higher risk for possible DEET side-effects. You decide -- is the bite worse than the preventative? Sometimes the answer is yes. — Michael Hodgson
|
More, more, more...The Mountain Zone Bookstore has a great selection of wilderness and backpacking books along with tons of other software, books, and guides on working and playing in the mountains.